Best Lobster in Orlando

Discover The Best Lobster in Orlando

Looking for the best lobster in Orlando? As warmer weather approaches, many of us have fresh lobster and New England seafood on our minds. If you are planning to dine out and want to satisfy your Maine Lobster cravings, we’ve got you covered! There are so many ways to enjoy the best lobster at The Nauti Lobstah, a locally owned seafood restaurant specializing in fresh Maine lobsters, New England seafood & premium steaks in Orlando.

For a lavish dining experience, try our baked lobster stuffed with scallops and shrimp, or our THREE POUND LOBSTER sauteed in butter and served completely shelled. Indulge in our extensive menu of mouth-watering Maine lobster dishes from lobster bisque and lobster rolls to classic boiled Maine lobsters and cracker-crusted lobster tails. Discover the Best Maine Lobster in Orlando for dine in or take out! Read on to explore all the favorite lobster menu items at The Nauti Lobstah.

Plenty of Options on The Lobster Menu at The Nauti Lobstah

1. Lobster Bisque

Our Lobster Bisque is a creamy soup with fresh Maine lobster, seasoned to perfection with a splash of Sherry and topped with a dollop of fresh homemade whipped cream. It is the essence of lobster in a bowl, made from scratch by Chef Mike! This guest favorite is prepared with lobster shells, lobster meat, seasonings, and cream for a decadent, must-try soup. The Nauti Lobstah serves the best lobster bisque in town, enjoy it by the bowl or by the cup. It’s a perfect starter to prep your taste buds for the “Maine” course!

2. Lobster Rolls - Or Lobstah Rolls, as we call them at The Nauti Lobstah!

New England is famous for fresh lobster rolls served on toasted, split-top buttery rolls! Whether you prefer hot or cold, we have the lobster roll for you! If you’re craving a chilled lobster salad roll, try our New England Lobstah roll filled with a generous portion of tender chilled Maine lobster meat gently tossed in Chef Mike’s signature dressing of house mayonnaise, fresh herbs, and lemon juice, piled on fresh bibb lettuce into a New England brioche roll.

If you’re looking for a buttery and warm lobster roll, the Connecticut Lobstah roll features succulent warm Maine lobster meat served with warm drawn butter. The combination of sweet Maine lobster served on a buttered and toasted brioche roll is heavenly! This has become the most popular lobster roll in Orlando. Which team are you on?

Nauti Lobstah Lobster Rolls are served with your choice of two sides including Homemade Potato Chips with Remoulade Sauce and Coleslaw, all made fresh in house. One bite and you’ll be transported to New England!

New England Lobster Roll at The Nauti Lobstah with chilled Maine Lobster meat tossed in house mayonnaise dressing.

3. Boiled 1 lb Maine Lobster

Grab your lobster cracker, put on the lobster bib and dig into our 1 pound whole boiled Fresh Maine Lobster. Served with drawn butter and fresh lemon as well as your choice of housemade side dish. If you love a deal, follow The Nauti Lobstah on social media for a can’t-miss weekly lobster special!

4. Boiled or Broiled Maine Lobster

For those who fancy traditional lobster dishes, our boiled or broiled Maine lobster is a must-try. Enjoy a broken down, tender 1-1/2 pound lobster that is boiled or broiled to your liking. Served with drawn butter and lemon, and your choice of two housemade sides.

5. Fisherman Style Baked Stuffed Lobstah

If you want to take your lobster dish to the next level, try our Baked Maine lobster stuffed with scallops and shrimp, then topped with buttery Ritz Crackers for a delightful taste of New England.

6. Twin Lobster Tail Dinner

Savor the goodness of twin lobster tails, broiled to perfection and topped with buttery Ritz Crackers. Served with Drawn Butter and a lemon wedge, and a choice of two sides. It’s the perfect meal for lobster lovers!

7. Lazy Man’s Lobstah

The ultimate indulgence! A Lazy Man’s Lobstah is named for the guest who’s lucky enough to be served a lobster that requires no effort whatsoever! Your Fresh Maine Lobster will be cooked, cracked open, and presented shelled and stuffed with shrimp and scallops, served in drawn butter, lemon and white wine sauce as well as your choice of two homemade sides. Available in 1.5lb & 3lb Maine Lobsters and a truly decadent experience for one or shared by two!

8. Lobster Tails

The Nauti Lobstah menu also includes an option to add a 7 oz Maine Lobster tail to any meal, which is ideal for those who want to try lobster perfectly prepared. If you’re craving surf and turf, add a lobster tail for the ultimate pairing to our premium 6 Oz. Filet Mignon, 12 Oz. Creekstone New York Sirloin Strip, or 12 Oz. Creekstone Ribeye.

If you prefer an all seafood feast, add a Maine Lobster tail to any of our fresh fish and shellfish selections and create your own Surf and Surf entree. Chef Mike’s rotating fresh catch selections offer a variety of options. Chilean Sea Bass, Swordfish, Grilled Mahi, Grouper, Grilled Salmon, Crabmeat Stuffed Flounder, Snapper or Snow Crab Legs are all enhanced with the addition of a fresh Maine lobster tail. The delicious options are to be explored at this seafood restaurant in Orlando.

Owner Chef Mike Rumplik with 3 lbs Lazy Man’s Lobstah at The Nauti Lobstah

What is Fresh Maine Lobster?

Fresh Maine lobster is renowned for its tender meat and delicate taste. Maine lobster’s distinctive flavor is owed to its rich diet of crustaceans and mollusks found in the region’s bountiful waters. When it comes to the finest seafood, Maine offers some of the world’s best lobster, thanks to its cold, clean waters and sustainable fishing practices. The Nauti Lobstah sources live fresh Main Lobsters from the finest New England seafood purveyors. This guarantees you’ll always get the best lobster in Orlando!

The Art of Cooking Lobster

Cooking lobster is an art form that requires precision and care. Chef Mike Rumplik, a graduate of Johnson & Wales Culinary University in Providence, Rhode Island is a master at cooking lobster and New England seafood delicacies. The Nauti Lobstah culinary team cooks each lobster to perfection. Whether it’s a classic 1 pound boiled Maine lobster served with drawn butter or a jumbo 3 pound lobster stuffed with scallops and shrimp, you can expect a dish that celebrates the natural sweetness and delicate texture of each Maine lobster.

Chef Mike shares his tips for cooking lobster in the Orlando Sentinel but we think the best lobster is the one someone prepares for us! That’s why we created The Lazy Man’s Lobstah. The key to a delicious lobster is always starting with a fresh lobster from Maine!

Prime Steaks & Cocktails and the best lobster in Orlando at The Nauti Lobstah

Never Stuffy! Casual Fine Dining at The Nauti Lobstah

The Nauti Lobstah offers a relaxed and welcoming dining experience, allowing you to savor the flavors of New England seafood and steaks without any pretense. The casual ambiance encourages you to roll up your sleeves and dive into your lobster feast. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a comforting seafood meal, the warm hospitality and laid-back atmosphere of The Nauti Lobstah create a memorable dining experience. However, while our relaxed atmosphere may invite you to sit back and feel at home, our kitchen serves dishes using the highest quality ingredients and expert culinary execution under the direction of Chef Mike. His decades of experience as Executive Chef of prominent resorts and hotels around the country is reflected in the delicious food we serve.

Savor New England Seafood and Maine Lobster in Orlando

While fresh Maine lobster is undoubtedly the star of the show, the Nauti Lobstah menu offers a range of seafood options, including Crab Legs, Oysters, Clams, Fish & Chips, Shrimp and Scallops, allowing diners to explore fantastic New England Seafood and create a personalized dining experience. Vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free options are also available, ensuring that everyone can find something to suit their dietary preferences.

The Nauti Lobstah offers friendly service, a welcoming atmosphere, and an exceptional dining experience. The team is always ready to assist with questions about the menu, provide recommendations, or special accommodations, ensuring that every visit is memorable and enjoyable. The Nauti Lobstah is a casual New England seafood and steak restaurant that embodies the essence of New England coastal dining. We take pride in our chef-created Maine lobster dishes which are always fresh, and never fussy! Indulge in the taste of fresh Maine lobster, and you’ll agree that The Nauti Lobstah is your perfect destination for the Best Lobster in Orlando.